crucifixion November 8 Chronological Bible Study

Timeline. Map. Go to today’s Bible reading (NIV) or alternate versions (use your browser arrow to return): Mark 15:22-41; Matthew 27:33-56; Luke 23:33-49; John 19:17b-37

Eight Responses to the Cross

The Conviction and Sentence

Jesus suffered what today might be considered a hate crime. He was hated by the religious leaders because he taught the Scriptures with authority, exposed their hypocrisy, and did miracles—all of which made him popular with common people and threatened their position and privileges in their Jewish society and nation. In recent Bible studies, we learned how Jesus was unjustly arrested, accused, beaten, and tried in the courts of law, even though he was innocent and not convicted of any civil crime (he was only convicted of a religious crime for claiming to be the Son of God, which was not punishable by any civil authorities).

Before Pontius Pilate, the religious leaders accused Jesus of subverting the nation, opposing the payment of taxes (Jesus said the opposite—see Luke 20:25), and calling himself a king (Luke 23:2). All of these charges were false, and the accusations did not stick. The Roman governor punished Jesus, but this did not satisfy the crowd of spectators.

The religious leaders and many of the Jewish people cried out for Jesus' crucifixion. “If you let this man go, you are no friend of Caesar. Anyone who claims to be a king opposes Caesar” (John 19:12b, NIV). The chief priests shouted, “We have no king but Caesar” (John 19:15, NIV).

Finally, because of political pressure by the Jewish leaders, Pilate turned Jesus over to Roman soldiers to be crucified.

Crucifixion—What is it?

The Bible Knowledge Commentary of the N.T., edited by Walvoord and Zuck, © 1985, pp. 88-89, 188, and 262 describe the crucifixion of Jesus, which we witness in today's Bible reading. What follows is a summary of it.

Crucifixion remains as one of the cruelest forms of capital punishment ever devised. The Roman government only does this to those who are considered the worst of criminals. This is why Pilate tried to deliver Jesus—he knew the religious leaders only wanted him killed because they were jealous of him. But Pilate caved to pressure from the crowd.

Those sentenced to die by crucifixion carry a one-hundred pound cross beam on which they will be fastened. Jesus is so weak from cruel treatment that the soldiers get Simon of Cyrene to carry his cross part of the way. When at the site of the crucifixion, Golgotha (a rocky hill which resembles a giant skull), Jesus is offered wine to drink to dull the senses and ease the pain he will bear. He refuses it.

Then, like the other criminals, his arms and legs are stretched out and nailed to a rough hewn wooden cross by long iron spikes into his hands and feet (or perhaps, the wrists and ankles, for they are considered part of the hands and feet and can bear the weight of the body). Through many long hours (and sometimes days) the criminals hang on the cross in absolute agony. Each attempt to push up so they might fill their lungs with oxygen is excruciating (unlike most who are crucified, Jesus had first been whipped—his back is a bloody, raw, painful mess, and this adds to his agony and loss of strength). Finally, the person who is crucified suffocates, not having the strength to push himself up anymore. If his death is not quick in coming, oftentimes the legs are broken to hasten his demise (Jesus dies after three hours of suffering, so his legs are not broken).

At the top of the crucifix post a sign is nailed listing his crimes. In the case of Jesus, the sign in Aramaic, Latin, and Greek reads, “This is Jesus of Nazareth, King of the Jews.” The purpose of crucifixion is to serve as an example to others of the penalty for rebellion against the Roman government. The irony is that Jesus is completely innocent of any wrong, and yet the sign is correct, for he is the King of the Jews.

The Eight Responses

What are the responses of the people who see Jesus crucified and how does Jesus respond?

1. Mocking and Insults

The religious leaders deny he is the Christ and want the sign above his head changed from “The King of the Jews” to “This Man claimed to be the King of the Jews” (John 19:19-22). Then all who pass by him mock and insult him, shaking their heads and saying,

“You who are going to destroy the temple and build it in three days, save yourself! Come down from the cross, if you are the Son of God!” Those crucified with him also heaped insults on him (Mark 15:29-30,32 NIV)

In the same way the chief priests, the teachers of the law and the elders mocked him.“He saved others,” they said, “but he can't save himself! He's the King of Israel! Let him come down now from the cross, and we will believe in him. He trusts in God. Let God rescue him now if he wants him, for he said, ‘I am the Son of God.’” (Matthew 27:39-43, NIV)

One of the criminals who hung there hurled insults at him: “Aren't you the Christ? Save yourself and us!” (Luke 23:39, NIV)

As the religious leaders and robbers mocked Jesus, many people today also insult, mock, and use his name in vain. How will Jesus respond?

2. Forgiveness

How does Jesus respond to their mocking? Does he rail back at them? Does he call fire down upon them? No, he says, “Father forgive them for they know not what they do” (Luke 23:34, NIV). Instead of Jesus calling curses upon his enemies, he prays that God will forgive them!

Christians, if Jesus could forgive his enemies who crucified him, we need to forgive those who hurt us. Jesus' forgiveness impresses one of the thieves on the cross.

3. Guilt and Believing

After a time on the cross, the heart of one of the thieves crucified beside Jesus is softened. He does not continue to have a mocking response like the other thief crucified with him (Luke 23:39-43). He acknowledges he is guilty for his crimes, fears God, and comes to believe in Jesus as the King and Savior of souls. The thief asks Jesus to remember him when he comes into his kingdom. Jesus’ silent testimony and his words of genuine forgiveness, even in the midst of intense suffering, deeply impacts the criminal.

Do we fear God? Do we know we deserve punishment for all the wrongs we have done? Like the thief on the cross, the good news is that if we turn from our sin and believe Jesus is the Savior of our souls, we can receive forgiveness and be assured of going to heaven (more...).

Christians, are others impressed that we do not curse God or man when we are suffering but endure it and are forgiving toward our enemies? Let this be our prayer.

4. Greed and Selfishness

The soldiers gamble over Jesus’ clothing to see who might win them (John 19:23-24). Some people are like vultures in their greed and selfishness when others die. Even today some make merchandise from the cross of Christ. How does Jesus respond?

5. Love

Contrasted with the greed and selfishness of the soldiers is Jesus' declaration from the cross. Jesus does not curse God because of his pain and agony, his feeling of being forsaken by his heavenly Father, and the injustice of his circumstances—he cares for others, especially those closest to him like his mother. In our colloquial terms, Jesus tells John, his closest friend on earth, “Take care of my mother” (John 19:26-27). She will soon need comfort, and he knows John will take good care of her. If we knew we were to suffer and die, if possible we should follow Jesus' example and try to provide for our loved ones.

6. Fear and Belief

When the Son of God dies there is thick darkness in the middle of the day, a terrible earthquake, and God splits open the veil of the temple from top to bottom. Symbolically, all who believe in Jesus can now enter into the presence of God (more...).

“When the centurion and those with him who were guarding Jesus saw the earthquake and all that had happened, they were terrified, and exclaimed, ‘Surely he was the Son of God!’” (Matthew 27:54, NIV).

Do we fear God when we hear of the crucifixion of Christ? Do we see God involved in nature and in the lives of people? Let’s fear him and believe!

7. Grief and Soberness

The crowd watches the terrible scene, they beat their breasts (a sign of grief), and then they go home. In this crowd are probably many people he has healed, given sight, hearing, or speech, raised to life, miraculously fed, and taught. They are sad but there is nothing they can do about it, and they go home.

There is nothing wrong with expressing grief, even for Christians, because God made us with emotions. Soberness at funerals is also good; we should each think about the shortness of our life and how to live it. Grief and sobriety are also the responses many have at Communion Services, where we remember the suffering and death of Christ on our behalf. In light of his death for us, how should we then live?

8. Disillusion and Shock

The family members, friends, and close followers of Jesus remain at the scene of the cross for awhile after he dies and watch what will happen next (Luke 23:49). His followers were so sure this was their Messiah. He was supposed to deliver them from oppression and Roman rule, give their nation peace and prominence, and reign as their king as the prophets of ancient times foretold. Now their savior and king is dead. They watch Jesus being taken down from the cross and buried before they go home. They are disillusioned and in shock.

What response do we have to the death of Christ? When we think about it, does it just make us sad and then we go on with our life? Or, are we in shock and grief from all that we hear about Jesus’ sufferings? Are we ready to trust in him for our spiritual life and happiness? Christians, do we forgive and love like Jesus?

Thinking about the death of Christ is indeed sad. It was a dark, black Friday for them, but it is called “Good Friday” today. It is called Good Friday because by his death he purchased our salvation. Praise God—this is not the end of the story—for Jesus would not stay dead in the tomb! As an old preacher once said, “Today is Friday, but Sunday is a comin’!” In our next two Bible studies we will look at the burial and resurrection of Christ.

What is the proper response Christians should have to the death of Christ? It is included in today’s Focus Verse.

Lessons to Live By

  • Many people mock Jesus today and use his name in vain. Jesus offers forgiveness for all who do wrong (John 3:15-17; John 5:24).
  • Christians, if our Lord could forgive his enemies who crucified him, we need to forgive those who hurt us.
  • Like the repentant thief on the cross, the good news is that if we turn from our sins and believe in Jesus, we can receive forgiveness and be assured of going to heaven (more...).
  • Christians, are others impressed that we do not curse God and man when we are suffering but endure it and are forgiving toward our enemies? Let this be our prayer.
  • If we knew we were to suffer and die, if possible we should follow Jesus' example and try to provide for our loved ones.
  • Do we see God involved in nature and in the lives of people? Let’s fear him and believe!
  • It is true that Jesus died for our sins, but three days later he arose from the dead to give us the hope of salvation!
  • Thinking about the death of Christ gives us a new reason to live. Listen to this encouraging song.

Focus Verse

Galatians 2:20 (NIV) “I have been crucified with Christ and I no longer live, but Christ lives in me. The life I live in the body, I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.”

Helpful resource: 7 Reasons Why I Believe in the Resurrection of Christ by Chip Ingram.

Watch a dramatized version of the crucifixion, burial, and resurrection of Christ

praying hands Write a private prayer response to today’s Bible study:

Please send your comments to

A Look Ahead: How is Jesus like A Planted Seed? How does this relate to us?

Previous Lesson  |  Next Lesson

Back to top of page
Return to Chronological Bible Studies main page
Go to Scriptures main page
Go to Topics main page
Go to Home page

Contact Us